The Fragile State of the Canadian Health Care System
The Canadian healthcare system has a long history of growth and development. For the past 60 years, it has made significant advances in several areas. Nonetheless, the current COVID-19 pandemic has shattered the healthcare system and will take years to recover. The Canadian healthcare system relies on a complex and fragmented public and private organization system (Kirkey, 2022). While this system is more than capable of delivering quality care to Canadians, it suffers from significant vulnerability to external shocks. Public funding and private insurance cover the bulk of health care costs, but the system is still susceptible to rises in costs and is also vulnerable to external shocks (Kirkey, 2022). Although some studies have indicated that Canada’s healthcare system is one of the best in the world, most research suggests that the system relies on a flawed system run by public and private organizations.
Description of the Causes and Problems in Canada’s Health System
Fragile is a word that is often used to describe items that are delicate or easily broken. Regarding the state of the Canadian healthcare system, weakness seems particularly appropriate. In recent years, many challenges have arisen that have put a strain on the system, from an aging population and the rising cost of drugs to medical errors and hospital overcrowding (Kirkey, 2022). As a result, there is a growing sense that the system is no longer sustainable in its current form.
One of the main problems is that Canada does not have a national health care plan. Instead, each province and territory has its health insurance program (Commonwealth Fund, 2020). Health care falls under the jurisdiction of provincial and territorial governments, and each manages its system. If not properly managed, some provinces may struggle with funding shortages or waitlist issues. Another problem is that private health insurance companies are allowed to operate in Canada. This means that some people have better coverage than others contributing to unfairness in the healthcare services offered. In addition, the cost of prescription drugs is a problem in Canada. Provincial health plans do not cover many drugs, and the cost of these drugs can be prohibitive for many people.
Additionally, the Canadian healthcare system lacks coordination between different levels of government. The federal government is responsible for funding health care, but the provincial and territorial governments deliver it (Brandt et al., 2018). This can lead to duplication of services and a lack of communication between different levels of government. As a result, patients can be neglected and not receive the care they need. A shortage of doctors and nurses also leads to a strain on the provision of medical services (Mallees, 2022). This deficiency is caused by an aging population and an increasing number of retirees. As a result, more patients need care, but fewer healthcare professionals are available for these services. The government offers a limited budget for training new healthcare professionals, leading to a shortage of qualified candidates.
A Brief History of the Healthcare System in Canada
The Canadian healthcare system is one of the world’s most efficient and equitable. Public health insurance provides universal access to medically necessary hospital and physician services. The roots of the Canadian healthcare system can be traced back to the 19th century when various charities and mutual aid societies began providing medical care to the poor. In 1867, the provinces of Ontario and Quebec established hospitals to treat contagious diseases (Rutty & Sullivan, nd). By the early 20th century, most areas had enacted legislation establishing hospitals and medical schools. However, it was not until Tommy Douglas’s government in Saskatchewan introduced universal hospitalization in 1947 that all Canadians had access to primary medical care.
Nonetheless, it was not until after the Second World War that the federal government began to play a more active role in funding and regulating health care. One way the government got involved is by delivering healthcare services to specific groups of people, such as veterans and First Nations (Health Policy in Ontario, n.d). Another way is through funding and regulating healthcare. The introduction of the Canada Health Act helped standardize health care across the country. The Canada Health Act (CHA or the Act) is federal legislation that governs provincial and territorial health insurance programs (Canada’s Health Care System, 2019). CHA sets the criteria and conditions to be complied with for the residents to receive total funding from the federal government. The Health Care Insurance Act requires provinces and territories to provide universal access to medically necessary hospital and physician services on a prepaid basis (Laberge, 2022). The Act bans the introduction of charges for medically necessary medical attention and hospital services.
In addition, the Act requires that provinces and territories establish and maintain national standards for these services. The Canada Health Transfer (CHT) is the primary mechanism through which the federal government provides financial support to provinces and territories for health care (Government of Canada, 2022). The Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI) is an independent organization that reports annually on the compliance of provincial and territorial healthcare programs with CHA principles. These include public administration, comprehensiveness Universality Portability Accessibility Equity, which embody key aspects of delivering equitable, accessible healthcare services in Canada.
The Canadian healthcare system has undergone significant changes and reforms since the introduction of the Canada Health Act. Before the Act, there was no universal health coverage in Canada, and access to health care services varied widely depending on an individual’s province of residence. The Act changed all that by establishing a set of minimum standards for health care services that all provinces and territories must meet to receive federal funding (Canada’s Health Care System, 2019). As a result of these reforms, all Canadians now have access to primary medical care regardless of where they live. In addition, the Act has helped protect patients’ rights by ensuring they cannot be denied care based on their ability to pay. While the Canadian healthcare system is not perfect, it has come a long way thanks to the introduction of the Canada Health Act.
It was not until the early 20th century that a nationwide healthcare system began to take shape. The establishment of provincial health insurance programs in the 1920s marked a significant step forward, and by the 1960s, most provinces had introduced some form of publicly funded health care. Since then, the Canadian healthcare system has continued to evolve, focusing on ensuring universal access to quality care. Over time, the responsibility for health care shifted to the provincial and territorial governments, and a series of reforms were enacted to improve access and quality.
Causes of the Healthcare System Decline
Over the years, several factors have contributed to the decline of healthcare services in the country. One of the most pressing issues facing the Canadian healthcare system is the shortage of healthcare professionals (Mallees, 2022). This scarcity is due to several factors, including an aging population, retirements, and attracting and retaining healthcare professionals. With an aging population and an increase in chronic conditions, healthcare services demand has soared (Haddad et al., 2022). Another factor is healthcare professionals are in high demand, and there are not enough to provide sufficient services to the population. This is caused by the high cost of higher education in the healthcare field, causing fewer individuals to enter these professions. The shortage of healthcare professionals has led to patients waiting for long to receive treatment (Mallees, 2022). The situation will only worsen as the population ages and the number of retirements increases. The government needs to invest more money in attracting and retaining healthcare professionals.
Another factor contributing to the decline of the healthcare system is a lack of funding. Despite promises from successive governments to increase funding, the reality is that many hospitals and clinics are operating on shoestring budgets (Department of Finance Canada, 2022). The government has been reluctant to raise taxes to pay for health care, resulting in chronic underfunding of the system. As a result, there are not enough resources to meet the needs of Canadians. Moreover, a lack of investment in primary care is another aspect leading to strain in healthcare provision (Squires et al., 2019). Primary care is the first point of contact for patients with health concerns and plays a vital role in preventing and managing chronic diseases.
The healthcare system is publicly funded and provides universal healthcare coverage to all Canadians. The high cost of prescription drugs and medical devices has strained the system (Vincent, 2020). Although the Canadian government has been slowly negotiating lower prices for these items, the primary care services in Canada are underfunded and understaffed, leading to long wait times and difficulty accessing care (Liddy, 2020). The aging population also strains the system as more people require access to long-term care and home care services. These problems have made the system unsustainable and have led to calls for reform.
The healthcare system is bureaucratic and inefficient, making the situation worse. The government bureaucracy has made it difficult for new technologies and treatments to be implemented promptly. The inflexibility of this government-run healthcare system is not designed to respond quickly to changes in demographics or technology. Although integrating new technologies was promising for the modernization of the healthcare system, the governance structure is inflexible (Couturier et al., 2021). For instance, remote care technologies such as remote diagnosis and care have taken a long time to be implemented by the government in rural areas (Mason, 2022). As a result, the quality of care in the Canadian healthcare system has declined in recent years.
Ways, the Federal Government, Addressed the Existing Crisis and Improved the Healthcare System
The federal government has implemented a National Health Care Strategy to improve the healthcare system. This strategic plan will be instrumental in achieving a better quality of care and reducing wait times. National Health Care Strategy is a long-term plan that sets out specific goals and objectives for improving the quality of care, reducing wait times, and ensuring that everyone has access to affordable, high-quality health care. The strategy is designed to make the health care system more efficient and effective and improve Canadians’ overall health. It also addresses mental health, Aboriginal health, and prescription drug coverage (Canada’s Health Care System, 2019). Ultimately, the strategy’s goal is to ensure that all Canadians have access to the best health care.
One way to use the National Health Care Strategy is the new Health Accord. A Health Accord is a formal agreement between Canada’s federal and provincial or territorial governments (Dhalla & Tepper, 2018). The Health Accord is an integral part of the Canadian healthcare system and helps to ensure that all Canadians have access to quality care. It aims to improve the coordination and delivery of healthcare services across the country. The Health Accord addresses several issues, including wait times, access to care, prescription drugs, and home care. It also includes a commitment to invest in new medical technologies and infrastructure (Dhalla & Tepper, 2018). It does this through an advisory council on implementing national principles on chronic disease prevention.
The government has also invested in training and education for doctors and nurses to provide better patient care. The government annually funds health education curricula for undergraduates and postgraduates and nationally coordinates the curriculum (Dhalla & Tepper, 2018). Additionally, it has enacted legislation that requires all healthcare workers to be appropriately trained and certified before they can practice (Dhalla & Tepper, 2018). By ensuring that these workers have the skills and knowledge to provide quality care, the government has helped improve the overall healthcare system.
The Consequences and Impacts of the Issue on Canadians and the Society
One of the most immediate consequences is an increased strain on the already overburdened healthcare system. With fewer resources available to meet the needs of patients, wait times for treatment and surgery will increase, and hospitals will be forced to ration care. This can lead to poorer health outcomes for patients and increased stress and anxiety levels. On a broader level, a decline in the health system can also lead to a decrease in the overall health of Canadians (Vaillancourt et al., 2021). With fewer resources available for preventative care and disease management, more people will become sick, placing an even more significant strain on the health system.
Ultimately, a declining health system can have far-reaching consequences for Canadians and Canadian society. When the health system is not working correctly, it strains all aspects of society. For example, if people cannot access timely and effective care, they may miss work, leading to lost productivity and income. Furthermore, people who cannot afford to pay for their health care may forego treatment altogether, leading to serious health consequences (Spadaro et al., 2022). Thus, a decline in the health system leads to a decrease in the overall health of Canadians and society.
When the health system is fragile, it puts immense strain on already overburdened hospitals and clinics. This can lead to longer wait times for care, increased risk of infection and illness, and even death. A declining health system also takes a toll on society as a whole. As more people become sick and require increasingly expensive care, the financial burden on the health system grows. This can lead to higher taxes, cuts to other essential services, and an overall decline in the quality of life for all Canadians.
Comparing the Canadian Healthcare System vs. the US
When it comes to healthcare, there are many different ways that countries can choose to organize their systems. In North America, the two main models are the single-payer system used in Canada and the hybrid multiple-payer system used in the United States. Both approaches have their strengths and weaknesses. The Canadian system, which is a single-payer system, means that only one government-run insurer exists. In contrast, the US has a hybrid multiple-payer system, including private insurers and government programs like Medicare and Medicaid (US vs. Canadian Healthcare: What Is the Difference? 2021). As a result, the Canadian system is generally much simpler and easier to navigate than the US system.
These two systems differ in the way that they are administered. The Canadian system is managed centrally by the government, while the US system is decentralized and run by individual states (US vs. Canadian Healthcare: What Is the Difference? 2021). This can impact things like wait times for care and the overall quality of care. Canada has generally shown better life expectancy and infant mortality outcomes.
In terms of coverage, both systems provide primary coverage for things like hospitalizations and doctor visits. However, the Canadian system covers a broader range of services, including prescription drugs and dental care. In addition, Canadians have access to free preventative care, such as vaccinations and cancer screenings (Canada’s Health Care System, 2019). As a result, Canadians generally have better access to care than Americans. However, it is worth noting that the US has made progress in expanding access to care through programs like Obamacare in recent years.
Another key difference is that all citizens automatically enroll in Canada’s public health insurance program. In the US, by contrast, only those who qualify for Medicaid or Medicare are automatically enrolled. This means that a significant portion of the US population is uninsured. Finally, it should be noted that the Canadian system is taxpayer-funded, while the US system relies heavily on private insurance companies. These companies typically charge much higher premiums than public insurers. Consequently, the Canadian healthcare system is much more affordable for most citizens than the US system.
Recommendations and Solutions to the Issue from a Political and Policy Perspective
With an aging population and increasing chronic disease rates, the demand for health services will only continue to grow. This places a significant financial burden on the system, which is already struggling to keep up with costs. To ensure that quality healthcare services are provided in Canada, all levels of the Canadian government must come together (Weeks, 2022). At the federal level, there needs to be increased investment in essential health services such as primary care and mental health. There also needs to be a greater focus on preventative care, as this can help to reduce the overall demand for the system (Weeks, 2022). The provincial and territorial governments need to work together more effectively to ensure that resources are being used efficiently and that there is a consistent level of care across the country.
There has been an ongoing debate about the future of healthcare in Canada. Some critics have called for a more significant role for private enterprises, arguing that this would improve efficiency and quality of care (Lee et al., 2021). Others have cautioned against such a move, arguing that it would lead to increased inequality and higher costs. The debate has intensified in recent months as the Canadian government has been exploring options for reform. While no decisions have been made, privatization is still a probable solution.
Proponents of privatization argue that it would lead to improved efficiency and better quality of care. They point to other countries, such as the United States, where private health insurance companies can provide high-quality care at lower costs than public systems (Lee et al., 2021). They also argue that privatization would create more competition in the healthcare market, leading to innovation and better quality of care. Opponents of privatization argue that it would lead to higher costs and greater inequality. They point out that private insurance companies are motivated by profit, not by providing good care (Lee et al., 2021). They also argue that privatization would lead to less accountability and transparency, as private companies are not subject to the same scrutiny as public institutions. The debate about healthcare reform is complex and dynamic, as both sides’ arguments are strong (Lee et al., 2021). Whatever direction the government decides to go with will have a profound impact on the lives of all Canadians.
As a result, the government must take action to strengthen the health system. One way to do this would be to increase funding for public hospitals. This would allow them to hire more staff, buy new equipment, and improve facilities. In addition, the government could create incentives for private hospitals to invest in the health system (Weeks, 2022). For example, it could offer tax breaks or subsidies for hospitals that make upgrades or expand their services. This can be done through government investment and private sector contributions. This can also help accommodate any future research into the health industry. By taking these steps, Canada can address its health system’s challenges. These changes could help to control costs and improve efficiency within the system.
The current healthcare system in Canada is facing immense pressure as the population ages, and chronic disease rates rise. In response, there is a shift towards providing care in the community rather than in a hospital setting. This not only helps to free up hospital resources but also allows for personalized and efficient care. As technological advances continue to expand options for remote monitoring and communication, more and more care can be provided outside of traditional clinical settings (Mason et al., 2022). This shift towards home and community-based care can also positively impact patient experience and overall health outcomes. However, it is vital to ensure that necessary supports are in place to make this shift successful, including appropriate funding and training for community healthcare professionals.
Canada’s healthcare system is unsustainable and does not adequately meet the needs of Canadian patients. The healthcare system faces several challenges, including an aging population, an increasing prevalence of chronic conditions, and a shortage of medical personnel. These challenges have left the system fragile and in need of reform. The good news is that some steps can be taken to improve the situation. They include reforming the policies on healthcare funding on affordable medication, encouraging preventative care, and expanding coverage to have more people would all help to make the system more sustainable. Ultimately, it will be up to the federal government to decide which changes are necessary to ensure that the healthcare system can meet the needs of all Canadians.
References
Brandt, J., Shearer, B., & Morgan, S. G. (2018). Prescription drug coverage in Canada: A review of the economic, policy and political considerations for universal pharmacare. Journal of Pharmaceutical Policy and Practice, 11(1), 28. Web.
Civilization. Ca—History of Canadian Medicare—1958-1968—The Medical Care Act, 1966. (n.d.). Web.
Couturier, Y., Wankah, P., Guillette, M., & Belzile, L. (2021). Does integrated care carry the gene of bureaucracy? Lessons from the case of Québec. International Journal of Integrated Care, 21(4). Web.
Dhalla, I. A., & Tepper, J. (2018). Improving the quality of health care in Canada. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 190(39). Web.
Government du Canada. (2019). Canada’s Health Care System. Canada.ca. Web.
Haddad, L. M., Annamaraju, P., & Toney-Butler, T. J. (2022). Nursing shortage – statpearls – NCBI bookshelf. Web.
Health policy in Ontario. (n.d.). Web.
Kirkey, S. (2022). “The lifeboat is full”: Canada’s healthcare system is failing. There is no easy solution. National Post. Web.
Laberge, M., Brundisini, F. K., Champagne, M., & Daniel, I. (2022). Hospital funding reforms in Canada: A narrative review of Ontario and Quebec strategies. Health Research Policy and Systems, 20(1), 76. Web.
Lee, S., Rowe, B., & Mahl, S. (2021). Increased private healthcare for Canada: Is that the right solution? Healthcare Policy | Politiques de Santé, 16(3), 30–42. Web.
Liddy, C., Moroz, I., Affleck, E., Boulay, E., Cook, S., Crowe, L., Drimer, N., Ireland, L., Jarrett, P., MacDonald, S., McLellan, D., Mihan, A., Miraftab, N., Nabelsi, V., Russell, C., Singer, A., & Keely, E. (2020). How long are Canadians waiting to access specialty care? Canadian Family Physician, 66(6), 434–444. Web.
Mallees, N. A. (2022). Canada’s healthcare labor shortage, a long time coming, requires a shift to team-based care. CP24. Web.
Mason, J., Brundisini, F., Hill, S., Kumar, D., & Rader, T. (2022). 2022 health technology trends to watch Top 10 list. Canadian Journal of Health Technologies, 2(3). Web.
Rutty, C., & Sullivan, S. C. (n.d.). This is Public Health: A Canadian History. CPHA. Web.
Spadaro, T., Anna, & Furman, A. (2022). Single-payer – good, bad, and ugly of the Canadian system. Journal Feed. Web.
Squires, J. E., Graham, I. D., Grinspun, D., Lavis, J., Légaré, F., Bell, R., Bornstein, S., Brien, S. E., Dobrow, M., Greenough, M., Estabrooks, C. A., Hillmer, M., Horsley, T., Katz, A., Krause, C., Levinson, W., Levy, A., Mancuso, M., Maybee, A., … Grimshaw, J. M. (2019). Inappropriateness of Health Care in Canada: A systematic review protocol. National Library of Medicine, 8(1). Web.
The expiry of the 2004 Canada Health Accord—What’s all the fuss about? Op-ed. (2014). Fraser Institute. Web.
Tikkanen, R., Osbor, R., Mossialos, E., Djordjevic, A., & Wharton, G. A. (2020). International Health Care System Profiles Canada. The Commonwealth Fund. Web.
US vs. Canadian Healthcare: What is the difference? Ross University School of Medicine. (2021). Web.
Vaillancourt, T., Szatmari, P., Georgiades, K., & Krygsman, A. (2021). The impact of COVID-19 on the mental health of Canadian children and Youth. FACETS, 6, 1628–1648. Web.
Vincent Rajkumar, S. (2020). The high cost of prescription drugs: Causes and solutions. Blood Cancer Journal, 10(6), 71, s41408-020-0338–x. Web.
Weeks, C. (2022). Meet the doctor on a mission to fix Canada’s health care crisis. The Globe and Mail. Web.
